Farmiga’s character Zoe has quite the power: she can kill someone by having sex with them. No, seriously. So you can imagine that’s a pretty big dilemma for her when she immediately finds herself attracted to Evan Peters’ frat boy with a conscience Kyle. And we can tease that the duo’s meeting is very reminiscent of how Leonardo DiCaprio and Claire Danes’ Romeo and Juliet met. AKA it’s totally epic.